Skip links

Beamforming Microphones vs. Traditional Microphones

What makes a microphone effective in a professional AV setup?

Is it how accurately it captures a speaker’s voice, how much flexibility it offers across different environments, or how well it handles background noise?

The answer largely depends on what microphone technology is being used. That is why choosing the right microphone is a very important part of any AV setup.

In this blog, we will talk about two common types of microphones: Beamforming Microphones and Traditional Microphones, and how they are used across AV setups. 

What are Beamforming Microphones?

Beamforming microphones use an array of multiple microphone elements, combined with Digital Signal Processing (DSP), to capture sound from specific directions. Instead of relying on a single microphone element, they analyse differences in the sound reaching each element to identify where a speaker is positioned. Using this information, the microphone creates focused pickup areas, commonly called beams, that capture speech while reducing unwanted ambient noise. Depending on the system, these beams can be configured to cover specific areas or adapt to different speaker positions.

One of the biggest advantages of beamforming technology is that participants do not necessarily need to sit close to or speak directly into a microphone. 

Advantages of Beamforming Microphones:

  • Directional audio capture: Focuses on voices within defined pickup zones while reducing unwanted sound from other areas.
  • Flexible coverage: Multiple pickup beams can accommodate several speakers across a room.
  • Reduced microphone clutter: A single ceiling-mounted array can cover areas that might otherwise require several individual microphones.
  • Integrated audio processing: Many models include features such as acoustic echo cancellation, noise reduction and automatic gain control.
What are Traditional Microphones?

Traditional microphones capture sound through an individual microphone element, using a defined polar pattern to determine which directions they pick up sound from. They come in several forms, including handheld, lavalier, boundary and gooseneck microphones. Each serves a different purpose, depending on the application and how speakers interact with the system. For example, gooseneck microphones are commonly used in conference rooms, boardrooms and discussion systems. They are positioned directly in front of the speaker, providing a consistent and controlled way to capture individual contributions.

Unlike beamforming microphones, traditional microphones generally require speakers to remain within a specific pickup area and maintain a suitable distance from the microphone. 

Advantages of Traditional Microphones:

  • Focused pickup: Directional polar patterns help capture speech from a specific position.
  • Individual control: Each microphone can be assigned to a particular speaker or participant.
  • Straightforward operation: Most traditional microphones require minimal configuration.
  • Application flexibility: Different microphone types can be selected for conferences, presentations, interviews and other AV applications.
What are the Differences Between Beamforming Microphones & Traditional Microphones?

Although both technologies serve the same fundamental purpose, their approach to audio capture makes them suitable for different environments.

  1. Audio Capture and Coverage: Beamforming microphones use multiple elements to create focused pickup zones across a room. This allows participants to speak naturally without having to position themselves directly in front of a microphone. 

Traditional microphones, on the other hand, rely on their individual pickup patterns. Speakers need to maintain a suitable position and distance to ensure consistent audio capture.

  1. Background Noise : Beamforming microphones can use DSP to focus on desired speech and reduce unwanted ambient noise. Advanced models may also include acoustic echo cancellation and automatic gain control, making them particularly useful in video conferencing environments.

Traditional microphones can also deliver excellent audio quality, especially when correctly positioned. However, additional DSP and audio processing may be needed to manage background noise and echo.

  1. Installation : Beamforming microphones, particularly ceiling-mounted models, help keep tables and workspaces free from multiple microphones and cables. 

Traditional microphones require physical placement at individual speaking positions, which involves additional cabling and equipment.

  1. Cost & System Requirements: Beamforming microphones generally involve a higher initial investment and may require configuration by an AV professional.

Traditional microphones are often more economical per unit and offer a practical solution for smaller, fixed-position setups. 

Audio-Technica offers solutions for both types of applications:

  • Audio-Technica ATND1061DAN is a beamforming ceiling array microphone designed for conference rooms, boardrooms and collaborative spaces. It features six individual output channels and supports up to 32 user-defined microphone pickup zones, allowing AV professionals to configure coverage according to the room layout. Its onboard DSP includes automatic mixing, acoustic echo cancellation, noise reduction, automatic gain control and four-band EQ. Dante connectivity further supports its integration into networked AV systems.

     

  • Audio-Technica ATUC-M43H, a traditional microphone, offers a traditional gooseneck microphone solution. Designed for compatibility with the ATUC-50 Digital Discussion System, it features a 430 mm double-gooseneck design for flexible positioning, a hypercardioid pickup pattern and a remote-controlled LED ring. Its double-layer pop filter and RFI shielding also help deliver reliable performance in conference and discussion settings.

Ultimately, neither technology is universally better. The best microphone solution is one that aligns with the room’s acoustics, seating arrangement, conferencing requirements and overall AV design. 

Leave a comment